Good Garage Scheme Seasonal Check

Is your car roadworthy and safe to drive for the winter? Book an essential 21 seasonal check for ultimate peace of mind: https://www.goodgaragescheme.com/seasonal_check. Keeping you safe on the roads and helping you avoid unwanted breakdowns and costs.

BMW & Mini Intake Valve & Port Walnut Blast Cleaning

We’ve had plenty of BMW N47 Engine’d cars in with us lately with the engine warning light present on the dashboard. Fault codes stored for measured air mass too low. Once the car has been diagnosed and possible other causes checked & ruled out. The warning light & engine fault is caused by carbon build up on the intake manifold & intake valves. Restricting air flow into the engine.

Once the manual carbon clean on the plastic manifold, intake valve & port walnut blast on the cylinder head (using walnut shell matter as it is softer than sand & if some small parts go into the engine cylinders, turbo or exhaust it is burnt off) is carried out, all is well again with correct air flow when measured by diagnostic equipment.

It is also recommended to remove the dreaded swirl flaps whilst the intake manifold is removed.

This occurs on several engine specific models across the BMW & Mini range.

If you suspect your vehicle may require this procedure please get in touch!
Please be aware we do book around 6-8 weeks in advance.

Mini Cooper 1.5i Petrol with x3 different Engine faults on one visit

We hope everyone had a Great Christmas & New Year! We’re now back open & happy to help where possible.

To start off 2023, here’s a Mini Cooper 1.5i with the 3 cylinder petrol engine fitted. This car kicked our backsides in 2022 with having x3 engine faults, that at first glance you would think are caused by one problem, though that didn’t seem to be the case…. as we found out!

This is quite a long read just so you’re aware…

The car arrived to us with the symptom of engine warning light on, then a cylinder misfire which would worsen on all cylinders making the car nearly un-drivable. The car had previously been to the Mini dealership (franchise) with a basic report that it will take around £4000 worth of repair, following a software update which did not fix the problem? Without any more detailed info we’ll have to diagnose this from scratch.

Road testing the vehicle first confirmed the engine would misfire until nearly un-drivable. With the car in the workshop plugged into the diagnostic computer. Fault codes were stored for combustion misfire with fuel injection cut off on all cylinders. Along with intake camshaft, installation faulty.

From experience we know that a misfire on all cylinders will be caused by the intake camshaft, installation faulty, as this will affect the amount & time of air entering the cylinder for combustion. If this is incorrect, then the burning of the injected fuel will be incomplete, causing a cylinder misfire.

So first we carry out tests on the intake Vanos system. This system uses engine oil pressure to adjust the timing of the engine back & fourth, to make the engine/ car better on performance, fuel & economy.

The oil pressure/ flow is controlled by electric valves on the end of the camshafts to adjust them back & fourth.

The results of the Vanos tests show the intake camshaft is stuck in one position & not able to move, causing these engine faults.

Next we checked the internal BMW & Mini forum for any known related faults for this issue, non we’re listed for this fault.

Before stripping the engine, first we swapped the camshaft position sensors from intake to exhaust as they are easy to access & quick to do. The fault remained on the intake camshaft proving the sensor is working correctly.

We have seen broken Vanos solenoid valves/ plungers on this engine model before so the next step is to remove the rocker cover to access the camshafts & timing chain assembly.

With the rocker cover removed we found the intake camshaft plunger pushed excessively outwards where the circlip that holds it in place has come off. We were unable to locate the circlip so it must be resting in the sump.

The intake Vanos plunger is defective causing this fault. A new part is required.

With the intake vanos valve plunger replaced & engine timed correctly. All parts refitted we cleared the fault memory & ran the engine.
Naturally expecting the fault to be fixed we were quickly disappointed when the engine ran poorly as before with the intake camshaft, installation faulty code returning.

Well what could this be? As we found a faulty component, now replaced & the engine timing is correct. Strange?

Next using an oscilloscope we checked the timing of the engine & plausibility of the crankshaft & camshafts sensor waveforms. All waveforms we’re good, but not sure if the timing is correct as we could not find a suitable known good for this engine.

This research has to be carried out on software/ systems from third party companies like ourselves as BMW & Mini do not provide known good timing waveforms, though it would be helpful if they did!

However, searching for this information on Google saved the day this time! As we found a video that a company had posted with the same fault we we’re experiencing.

The fault code is actually stored by the engine thinking the timing is incorrect. The engine control unit – ECU reads the position of the engine camshafts from ‘increment gears’ on the end of the camshafts. Once the engine ecu knows the position of the camshafts it can use the Vanos to adjust accordingly.

On this engine model, the increment gears are heat pressed onto the hollow camshafts when manufactured. In previous years on all cars the camshafts were made from solid cast iron then ground to suit or the increment gear was bolted on rather than pressed.

Unfortunately what has happened on this camshaft is the increment gear has worked slightly loose over the years causing it to move/ spin slightly from its correct position.

Therefore the engine ecu thinks the camshaft is in the incorrect position, as the fault code states.
Next we removed the rocker cover to inspect the intake camshaft increment gear & compared to a known good position from the video on google.

As suspected the gear had spun around slightly to an incorrect position. (Lucky we had this picture or putting the gear back in the correct place would be impossible without a replacement camshaft).

A new camshaft is around £600 and we did not feel it necessary to replace it for this type of fault. We then tapped the increment gear back to its correct position & tack welded in place to prevent it moving again in future, much more cost effective! We also tacked welded the exhaust camshaft to prevent any future faults.

With all parts refitted we cleared the fault memory & ran the engine. Hey-presto the engine now ran & idled perfectly with no fault code returning. Looks like we’ve sorted this one!

We road tested the car which now had the correct amount of power……. However now & again the engine would have a slight hic-up/ misfire, not good!

We then drove the car at excessively low rpm to make the engine misfire more putting the engine warning light on.

With the car back in the workshop we checked the fault memory again. Misfire fault stored for cylinder 2. Is this fault code stored as we did not put the increment gear in the perfect place or do we have another fault?

A simple way to check for a faulty cylinder component is to swap to other cylinders & see if the fault migrates. So we interchanged the spark plug from cylinder 2 to 3. And the ignition coil from cylinder 2 to 1. Cleared all fault memory.

Road tested the car again as before until the engine light returned on.

Rechecking the fault memory the misfire was now present on cylinder 3, proving a faulty spark plug!!

All spark plugs we’re replaced & faults cleared. Road testing the car again & it now drives perfectly, all faults rectified!

Of course this write up is the simplified version & having x3 faults of a similar nature does make you feel like you’re going crazy!

Fortunately we got there in the end, with a very cost effective repair! Google saved some time on this occasion & I’m sure we will see this fault again soon but will now know exactly where we’re heading first!

Happy New Year from all of us!

Video of the moving increment gear on the camshaft to follow…

Merry Christmas!

Thank you to all our loyal customers for another great year during 2022.

We are now closed for Christmas & New Year and will reopen on Tuesday 3rd of January & will respond to all enquiries as soon as we can on our return.

Merry Christmas & Happy New Year

Mini Cooper 2016 fault diagnosis and repair

Mini Cooper 2016 – Left headlight not working, sidelight ring permanently staying on even when turned off/ locked & intermittent warning lights on instrument cluster
Recently in the workshop with us, this Mini with the faults listed above.

We Road & functioned tested the vehicle to confirm the fault, all present as described.

A Diagnostic fault scan carried out showed several faults & no communication to the left headlight module. We removed the left headlight to access & check the power supply, earth (load tested) and communication wires to the headlight module. All we’re present & correct, so it would seem the headlight module is defective. However it would be foolish not to swap the headlights from side to side to see if the fault migrates confirming the issue, as it is simple to do this on Mini’s.

With the headlights swapped from side to side. The fault remained on the left side…. Good job we didn’t replace the headlight module following the first check as this wouldn’t of fixed this problem!

We next rescanned the car for faults with the headlights swapped over which still had no communication to the left headlight module. Next using an oscilloscope we checked the communication wires at the left headlight module. Working backwards from the headlight we wiggled the wiring loom in the engine bay whilst inspecting the signal on the scope.

Once near the right side bulkhead wiring loom we found the communication scope pattern would flicker & not show a correct pattern, that could well be the problem here.
Fortunately we have seen this wiring loom issue a couple of times as it seems to be becoming a common problem. The loom insulation from factory is not up to scratch which allows corrosion inside the wiring, causing various issues. Bizarrely only affecting the right side bulkhead loom, not the left side.

Checking the internal BMW & Mini known fault forums we have access to, showed we were correct as this fault is listed, with headlights not working along with various other faults that we had stored in the cars fault memory. Let’s replace this wiring loom, which is quite labour intensive with all the wires that need cutting inside the vehicle, then crimping back together. Fortunately with this being a common problem, Mini sell this as a kit with repair instructions to aid us. With the loom replaced & insulated correctly. The left headlight was now functioning again correctly. A job well done.

Correct Information, equipment, experience & practice allow us to diagnose and repair your BMW & Mini correctly, in good time.
Thanks for taking the time to read this
Burch Motor Works

Christmas & New Year Opening Hours

Please find our Christmas & New Year Opening Hours in this video created by our much loved by customers receptionist Dave ?

Once again thank you to all our kind and loyal customers for another great year, they keep flying by!

? Burch Motor Works

BMW i3 Engine warning light on & range extender not starting – only battery power available

Recently in the workshop, this BMW i3 which had a permanent engine warning light on the dash, then when driven another warning light on the I-drive would appear for ranger extender not available, only high voltage battery available.

The range extender on this i3 model is basically a two cylinder motorbike engine which intermittently cuts in & out when required to provide extra charge to the high voltage battery, to ‘extend the range’ of the battery/ vehicle.For simplicity in this post we are now going to call the range extender, the engine!

We road tested the vehicle to confirm the fault. Once in the workshop connected to our BMW diagnostic tool which showed x2 related faults to the range extender. Crankshaft position sensor, signal not plausible & oil pressure switch not plausible.

First we checked the engine oil level to make sure there was oil present in the engine, which there was! Next step is to attempt to run the engine to check if the crank sensor & oil pressure sensor will display any plausible readings. There is a procedure on the BMW diagnostic system which allows us to start the engine.
Once pressed the engine started, much to our surprise as on most conventional engines a crank sensor fault can prevent an engine from starting/ running from the engine ecu not knowing its position to activate ignition & fuel systems in the right order.

With the engine running we inspected the live data, engine speed – rpm was displayed correctly & oil pressure was good. On some engines, the ecu can use the camshaft position sensor instead, should the crank position sensor fail. As a fail safe to keep the engine running.

Ok, so was this fault a one off, as everything is checking out correctly at the moment? Next we cleared the fault memory, road tested the vehicle again. No warning lights had returned on but the engine did not cut in (then out) as expected. Once back on the BMW diag tool, the crankshaft position sensor implausible signal fault code has returned.

Next step is to check the signal from the crank sensor, to see if the correct signal is being produced. With the wiring diagram & wiring connections located at the engine ecu. Power supply & earth to the sensor are present & correct. We then started the engine & measured the output signal waveform with an oscilloscope. No waveform present on the signal line, just a flat 5 volts on the line, meaning the crank sensor is defective or the wire between the sensor to ecu is broken. Unfortunately the location of the crank sensor is not easily accessible on this model, sandwiched between the engine to the rear bulkhead. The repair instructions state the engine has to be removed to access the sensor to replace it meaning checking the wiring between the sensor to the ecu is not possible without removing the engine.

The decision was taken to replace the crank sensor. With the assistance of our excellent apprentice with long arms and small hands. He carried out contortion to replace the crank sensor without removing the engine, saving the owner a pretty penny!! Once the sensor was replaced, we checked the signal waveform again with the engine running which now shows the correct waveform
Cleared all fault codes. Road tested the vehicle whilst inspecting the live data to make sure the engine cuts in & out when required, which it did!

Fault rectified, money saved!
Burch Motor Works